Plugin Suggestion by Zatharel

[Zatharel]

This is an automated message from the Plugin Suggestion form.

Zatharel has made a suggestion for zero.minr.org

Plugin Name: Build Commands & Build Commands SE

URL: http://www.planetminecraft.com/mod/build-commands/

Reasons for suggestions: This would be very useful for maps.
It's not a plugin, it's a bunch of worldedit scripts.
There are a lot of things here that can be used for maps: custom trees, spikes rising from the ground, vines, giant mushrooms, etc.
I don't know if this is compatible with the latest versions of Minecraft, but it'd be good to have if it is.

 

[skyerzz]

I dont really thing this is a good idea, since as i see it, its an extension of worldedit, in which case, ops would have to do every of that for you. It'll remove an aspect of the fun of building a map by yourself. And ops already help out a lot with op-stuff anyways, lets not put more pressure on them

 

[Zatharel]

I dont really thing this is a good idea, since as i see it, its an extension of worldedit, in which case, ops would have to do every of that for you. It'll remove an aspect of the fun of building a map by yourself. And ops already help out a lot with op-stuff anyways, lets not put more pressure on them

you don't get what I meant by this.
I never suggested this for admins to help us with like they do with ScriptBlocks, basic WorldEdit, etc.
I suggested this specifically for their maps.
This is just a random example, but don't you thing Packs' Congo would look better if it had something more than a vanilla jungle in it?

 

[skyerzz]

Being really honest here: no.
I myself like how everything is what you create, or let minecraft vanilla create for you. Not user-made stuff which you can just import, that will remove a lot of the creativity you have to use, which, can make some parts of maps look the same as others. But that's my personal opinion about that, and im sure a lot of people will have other opinions with that. And that's allright! Though you are wrong. I appreciate that you have other opinions. I'm actually curious what other people think of it

 

[rickyboy320]

Being really honest here: no.
I myself like how everything is what you create, or let minecraft vanilla create for you. Not user-made stuff which you can just import, that will remove a lot of the creativity you have to use, which, can make some parts of maps look the same as others. But that's my personal opinion about that, and im sure a lot of people will have other opinions with that. And that's allright! Though you are wrong. I appreciate that you have other opinions. I'm actually curious what other people think of it

It isn't really user-imported is it... It's more like a brush that you can use to your advantage, but has more options etc..
So this isn't your creativity, this is a tool to express your creativity easier. I get why Zath suggested it, but it would impact only the admins, I suppose they should tell if they like it or not, because we're not even going to be able to use it.
Congo is placed in a jungle right now, what Zath probably means is that Packs could've made something somewhat more impressive with not a lot more effort if he would've used this tool. Tools are there all around!

You can obviously say (using a metaphor here) I'm going to create my whole game myself! But you could use tools to make one, like engines or whatever, this thing is basically an add-on for World Edit, so why not adding this to their arsenal?

It's not really neccesary, but it can be a useful tool to the admins.

 

[Zatharel]

Being really honest here: no.
I myself like how everything is what you create, or let minecraft vanilla create for you. Not user-made stuff which you can just import, that will remove a lot of the creativity you have to use, which, can make some parts of maps look the same as others. But that's my personal opinion about that, and im sure a lot of people will have other opinions with that. And that's allright! Though you are wrong. I appreciate that you have other opinions. I'm actually curious what other people think of it

So you're against non-user made stuff that you can import, but you're all for something vanilla Minecraft generates for you?
That's actually almost exactly the same thing.

This isn't importing things like built and ready schematics into a world, this is using a couple of brushes to create something on your own.

But yeah, what ricky said - it isn't our decision if this gets added or not, this is only a suggestion as said in the post title.