Minr Mafia 10 Chinatown

[ElectroUnderwear]

This is not a good idea. People often stay quiet because they don't want to be targeted right away. This happens all the time, so you can't just lynch people because they didn't say anything the first few days.

Not right off the bat, of course, but if we try to get their attention and they never saying anything anyway, that's a sign that they aren't paying attention to the game and are therefore useless to the innocents' cause. It's not an amazing plan, but it's sometimes the best one available.

I didn't vote for forgot because there were already enough people voting for him. I rated his post agree instead.
Also, for the person who can talk. If you're in a conversation with the man who can talk, can he turn you in can kill you? Because if so that defeats the purpose of having him as he can just go around to anyone and get their info then turn them in and be safe. Game could be over in one turn

Henni earlier confirmed that anyone can safely converse with that person, and that you can even start the conversation.

 

[TheForgottenUser]

I've had a little time now to talk with some players, and we've come up with the following thoughts on the game so far:
​

Roles:
I know (or at least think I know) a few of the roles now. I'm not going to say who's who just for confidentiality's sake, but we have a decent idea of how many of each role we're dealing with.

Innocents
Villagers: 3-4. Any more and the game's probably too plain, any less and the role becomes rather pointless.
Sheriff: 1. There's no point in having multiple, and they'd have to vote, and then there could be a tie, etc.
Deputy(ies): 2. I've been told there are two deputies, despite my originally only thinking there had been one. If someone could prove otherwise, I'd be happy to hear it, but I don't think the mafia has the guts to lie about something as big as this.
Judge: 1. Same reasons as Sheriff.
Guard: 1-2. Intuition tells me there's more than one, especially based upon what I've heard and what's been said in the thread so far. People I've talked with this about seem inclined to agree.
Mr. Innocent: 1-2. I doubt there's more than two, but there's obviously one, and there could be two.

Raiders
Mafia Boss: 1. Same reason as Sheriff/Judge.
Cobra: 2. I don't think there'd only be one of this role, as it's already sort of weak for a Mafia role. Unless it came down really close to the wire, the role's fairly useless with just one Cobra. It makes more sense for there to be two.
Vampire: 1. I'm still not sure what the role does, decently sure it's role-blocking, but I'd guess only one.

Other Thoughts:
For once, I'm somewhat at a loss for strategies. There is too large a variety of roles for a role-claim strategy to work. The mafia would blend right in, especially because we aren't sure of the actual numbers of each role. It'd also be much too risky for anyone to contact each other unless they're positive each party is innocent. If anyone has a good idea, I'd love to hear it.

I don't really have any suspicions right now. I always suspect sren, but whenever I say he's Mafia, he ends up being good. :/ Since he seems to be his normal self I'd reckon he's innocent for now.

I'd also like to make one point, and a suggestion. The point: The secondary Mafia roles (Vampire & Cobra) can do their moves tonight. Henni said nobody would die by the Mafia night one, yet asked the baddies to send in their moves. This only makes logical sense. The suggestion: If you're going into the mines, please tell us before you head in, and remain active the two days after so we know you're still alive.

Thoughts? -TFU

 

[Srentiln]

I'd like to point to something that was said in the role explanation:

-Innocents -Villager: This role can do the 2 special events.
-Sheriff: This role can put someone in jail for 1 night. Knows who the deputy is . Can also do the 2 special events.
-Deputy: Can check for a players role once every 2 nights. Can do the 2 special events.
-Judge: Decides if the players in jail will die or be set free. Can do the 2 special events.
-Guard: Will protect a player and die in there shoes if that players is targetted by someone. Cannot protect from lynching. Can not participate in the 2 special events.(if he dies the person he protected knows the killer)
-Mr.Innocent: Will escape death once, can do the 2 special events.(if he dies knows the person who killed him)
-Raiders(no raider can do a special event)

Special Events: There are 2 special events that can a player do. The 1st one is going on a mining trip doing this will give you 1 piece of gold. But if you get killed in the mines your body will only be found 2 days later. The 2nd one is going to the local pub. This costs you 1 piece of gold and makes sure you do not get killed for one night. You can't mine 2 days in a row.

Now, I don't know if the pub special event also protects from a lynch vote, so I am asking @henniboy321 for some clarification on that point. If it does, then we have a built-in test for confirmation of most innocent roles.

Also, there is no specification that a lynch only happens during the day in this thread or the general rules, there is only the presumption of it from other games, which would kill this idea anyway. Still, it's a thought.

 

[henniboy321]

You can only lynch at day also I will update every day between 7-9 pm uk time

 

[Srentiln]

well, so much for that thought then, lol

 

[Pieceofcheese87]

Glad to hear i've been nothing but useless so far

 

[henniboy321]

Ooh sorry sren overread something you said. The pub is only avaible at night as well as mining.

 

[Srentiln]

I knew that part, I just wasn't sure on the lynching during the day/night since it wasn't specified. Since it only happens during the day, my idea is moot.

 

[henniboy321]

It is now Day 2

The sun rises. The city wakes up. Quickly everyone was already working to restore Chinatown. It was this day. This special day thought blie. This moment I would finally meet the sheriff to discuss certain business. But 1st he had to find ricky and cory. Those 3 were called together by the sheriff to discuss some important business. Blie found ricky who totally forgot he was called by the sheriff. He was ready to hunt some animals because they are running low. He just asked creeper to do the hunting and joined blie. They still didn't find cory after couple of hours so went to the sheriff on their own. Already seeing cory there, he asked why he didn't wait for them. Cory told them he found distinct hanging above his door. Who could've done such a cruel thing??

DistinctFreedom the Innocent Vilager died

You are now able to lynch someone.

 

[MeisterXehanort]

Are we told which role he was, or is that not revealed upon death?

 

[henniboy321]

sorry edited

 

[DistinctMadness]

I thought you couldn't die night one

 

[rickyboy320]

The 1st day and night will be peacefull without any deads and you can all discuss you strategy. By day 2 You will all need to vote for 1 person who has the right to speak outside this thread over MM10. Any other players who were not voted cannot talk outside this thread except with people who got voted.

I assume day and night one was over without us noticing. So it's day 3 now? (Since we already voted for a talker, and according to here that happens on day 2)

 

[henniboy321]

I thought you couldn't die night one

I said the 1st 2 days which was saturday and sunday

I assume day and night one was over without us noticing. So it's day 3 now? (Since we already voted for a talker, and according to here that happens on day 2)

Day one was where you voted it is now day 2

 

[henniboy321]

It is now night 2

Nothing happend. People that were muted/capture or in jail are now free again.

Guards, Sheriff / judge, mafia send in your moves please.

 

[Jkjkelly1]

Can we get a little more warning of when days/nights will end?

Just a couple hour notice would be nice to finish up thoughts.

 

[henniboy321]

I will do whenever I got time but I told you already I will be updating between 7-9 pm UK time

 

[TheForgottenUser]

All right who muted me? : p

EDIT: btw, it seems the cobra is more powerful than I would have though based on its' explanation. If you talk outside or inside the thread, you are mod-killed. This also applies to me despite the power you gave me.

 

[Jkjkelly1]

I was jailed :|

 

[Srentiln]

Nothing happened to me, I was Doc...or Dopy...or Grumpy...or Happy...or Bashful...or Sleepy...or Sneezy